Robin Murphy's family faces new scrutiny of 1995 disappearance
A multi-agency task force has reopened the case of the Carmel teen who vanished in 1995, revisiting evidence linked to a former suspect.
By Andres Henderson ·

Robin Murphy, a 17-year-old resident of Carmel, New York, disappeared on April 9, 1995, after leaving a shopping center where she was employed. More than three decades later, her family is watching a renewed push by law enforcement to solve the mystery of her vanishing.
The case resurfaced in a new ABC '20/20' episode that aired on November 13. The program details the timeline of events following Murphy's last known movements. That night, she met with a friend at the shopping center before failing to return home. Her brother, Jamie Murphy, received the news while working at his own job. He described an immediate intuition that something was wrong, a feeling that has persisted for thirty years.
The initial investigation focused on the area behind the ShopRite in the same complex. On April 13, 1995, four days after Murphy went missing, a group of coworkers and friends organized a civilian search of the woods. They recovered her work schedule and a paystub. Later, searchers found her wallet and identification near a dumpster at the shopping center. Jamie Murphy noted that finding these items made the situation feel more real, despite the hope of recovery.
Police interviews with local employees led investigators to Howard Gombert. Gombert operated a laundromat in the shopping center and had become friends with Murphy through a shared connection with his girlfriend at the time. In 1995, Gombert told detectives he met Murphy for ten minutes that night. He stated she walked toward a fast food restaurant where her boyfriend worked before he returned to his business. He denied any knowledge of her fate.
Gombert's profile changed in 2000 when he was arrested and convicted of sexually assaulting his ex-girlfriend. He received a four-year prison sentence. He was subsequently convicted of sexually assaulting a seven-year-old girl in Connecticut, adding thirty years to his total sentence. During a search of his residence, police seized a tan suitcase containing Ziploc bags filled with women's underwear. Investigative journalist Paul Solotaroff noted that officers also found collections of jewelry and handbags.
DNA testing on the underwear yielded a conclusive match to Robin Murphy. Gombert maintained that the items were not his and did not originate from Murphy. He has offered varying explanations for the other seized items over the years, including claims that he purchased them from a thrift store. Carmel police publicly identified Gombert as a suspect in 2000 but never filed formal charges. In a recent email to '20/20,' Gombert denied involvement in her disappearance. He is scheduled for release from prison no later than January 2027.
A multi-agency task force recently formed to reinvestigate the case. Representatives for the group declined an interview request but issued a statement acknowledging the severity of the case. They stated they understand the Murphy family's desire for answers after three decades of uncertainty.
Jamie Murphy continues to hold onto the possibility of finding his sister. He described the process as an emotional rollercoaster, noting that hope often leads to disappointment. The family awaits the results of the new task force's work as the anniversary of the disappearance approaches.






