Pakistan weighs plan to create new provinces as debate over cost and constitution grows
Pakistan's defence minister has suggested new provinces could be created by the New Year, but the proposal faces constitutional hurdles, coalition resistance and unanswered questions about money and water.
By Luca Fernandez ·

Pakistan could have multiple new provinces as early as the New Year, Defence Minister Khwaja Asif has said, in the strongest indication yet that a controversial proposal to redraw the country's administrative map is gaining momentum.
"My own view is that New Year will see this, the new system also, God willing," Asif, a senior leader of the governing Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) party, told a private news channel programme this week. He stressed, however, that he was offering a personal assessment. "I have no inside information at this time, and even if I did, obviously I cannot spill it over on a show," he said.
The idea was first floated publicly nearly four months ago by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, who told an economic summit in Islamabad on July 30 that Pakistan needed new administrative units to improve governance. Naqvi is considered a close confidant of military chief Field Marshal Asim Munir. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has spoken of creating 12 to 15 provinces through consensus, though no draft constitutional amendment, agreed number of provinces or timetable has been made public.
Supporters argue the existing four provinces, Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan, are too large to deliver services to a population of about 250 million, and that a 2010 constitutional amendment meant to devolve power to districts has failed. "Powers and resources were taken in the name of the people and parked in the chief minister's house," federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal of the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan said in television interviews this week. Kamal noted that December is politically significant, with Senate elections due early next year followed by the federal budget in June.
Creating new provinces would require amending the constitution under Article 239, which demands two-thirds support in both houses of parliament, plus two-thirds backing in the assembly of any province whose boundaries change. Abdul Moiz Jaferii, a Karachi-based constitutional lawyer, said no other route could be used, and questioned whether new provinces would necessarily improve governance. A previous attempt in 2013, when the Senate passed a bill to create a Bahawalpur Janoobi Punjab province, lapsed when the National Assembly's term ended without taking it up.
Naqvi has suggested the question could be put to a referendum under Article 48(6), telling reporters in Lahore last week that he would accept whatever the public decided. Legal experts note, however, that a referendum result is not binding and cannot substitute for the amendment process. Pakistan's three previous referendums, in 1960, 1984 and 2002, were all held under military rulers.
The financial stakes are considerable. Provinces currently receive 57.5 percent of the federal tax pool, worth 8.64 trillion rupees ($31.2bn) this financial year, divided by population. The constitution does not specify how a province's share would be split among new units carved from it. The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy estimated in October that dividing Punjab into three would cost 46.9 billion to 56.2 billion rupees a year, while a scenario converting all 30 divisions into provinces would cost up to 730.3 billion rupees ($2.64bn). Water sharing under the 1991 Water Apportionment Accord, which is not part of the constitution, also remains unaddressed.
The proposal has exposed coalition tensions. The Pakistan People's Party, the PML-N's main partner, governs Sindh, where the provincial assembly passed a resolution in September rejecting any division. President Asif Ali Zardari reiterated that opposition in a meeting with Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Saturday, local media reported. Kamal, a former Karachi mayor, countered that Karachi should become a provincial government in its own right.
The PML-N says it has no formal policy and will state its position when the matter reaches parliament. Naqvi has insisted no change will proceed without coalition agreement. "If they all agree, everything will happen," he said in Lahore. "Otherwise nothing will."






