AdvertiseDonate
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Today’s news, without the noise.
Breaking Blast · 230 S Broad St, 17th Floor, Philadelphia, PA 19102

Documents reveal Acma leadership overturned staff assessment of ABC War Memorial report

Freedom of information documents show regulatory staff initially found no impartiality breach in a Four Corners investigation before Acma’s leadership reached the opposite conclusion.

By Luca Fernandez ·

Illustration for: Documents reveal Acma leadership overturned staff assessment of ABC War Memorial report
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The leadership of the Australian Media and Communications Authority overturned its investigators’ preliminary assessment that an ABC Four Corners episode about the Australian War Memorial redevelopment had met impartiality requirements, documents released under freedom of information show. The internal records reveal that staff subsequently revised their report to reflect the authority’s finding against the broadcaster.

The documents, first reported by the ABC’s Media Watch, include several drafts prepared by specialist regulatory staff that supported the reporting of Gold Walkley award-winning journalist Mark Willacy. Their analysis distinguished criticism of the redevelopment’s management from partiality towards its opponents. Staff also noted that impartiality did not require all perspectives to receive equal airtime or every aspect of an issue to be covered.

Internal meeting notes from January questioned whether the concerns justified a breach finding and concluded that they probably did not. Another note suggested the ABC could have provided greater clarity while still finding, on balance, that no breach had occurred. By March 2026, however, board meeting notes recorded that authority members had determined the episode, Sacrifice, breached the impartiality provision of the ABC Code of Practice 2024.

Correspondence shows that the board had sought a more critical tone during the investigation. Feedback questioned whether the draft adequately conveyed concerns that the reporting had approached the limits of acceptable practice. Much of the released material appeared to accept the investigators’ conclusions while encouraging stronger criticism. After the board rejected the recommendation, a staff member discussed incorporating additional arguments into the existing report and removing repetition created by those revisions.

The dispute began with a complaint from the Australian War Memorial to the ABC, which the broadcaster’s independent ombudsman dismissed. Kim Beazley, chair of the memorial’s council, then lodged a formal complaint with Acma. When the regulator announced its finding in September, chair Nerida O’Loughlin said the combined effect of the episode’s framing, emotive language and differing treatment of interviewees had unfairly favoured critics of the redevelopment.

ABC managing director Hugh Marks challenged that decision in September, arguing that the criticism was unfair and could discourage investigative journalism in Australia. The broadcaster also said the finding unfairly called the reporter’s integrity into question and failed to recognise the program team’s work to ensure impartiality. Asked about the newly released documents, the ABC declined further comment and referred to its earlier statement supporting the team, its processes and the broadcast.

Acma said the released documents contained informal discussions between colleagues that should be considered in context. It described investigations as a collective, consultative process, with final decisions resting with its six authority members. The regulator maintained its finding, saying it had considered the episode, the complaint, ABC submissions and the analysis and advice produced during the investigation.

A former authority member told the Guardian that disagreements between members and staff over contentious matters were common, but reversing an investigation’s finding was “pretty rare”.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Breaking Blast in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Breaking Blast in your inboxToday’s news, without the noise. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.